Shoe Throwing : Indian Election 2009

When Muntadhar al-Zaidi hurled his shoes at the thenintegrity, commitment is on the wane and worst
US President George Bush, little did he know that hisvictims are the millions of countrymen. They have
method of getting a point across would soonhardly any right to speak against existent
become viral across continents.discriminations, exploitations, repressions, corruptions
In India too, the trend seems to have caught on. Forand harassments. What can they do except hurling
indeed, the humble footwear has become theshoes? Recently Congress MP Naveen Jindal and
preferred weapon of choice among a section ofBJP’s projected prime ministerial candidate LK
Indians who wish to voice their resentment and beAdvani had the taste of same in election meetings. It
heard over the din of political platitudes beingis said more are on the cards and the politicians are
mouthed by leaders in the face of the Assemblygetting nervous witnessing this latest expression of
Elections.fury. It may be some of protesters are efficient in
First, Jarnail Singh (photo here), a journalist, hurledtargeting. What will happen then? Is the Indian mass
one of his sneakers at the Union Home Minister P.getting more conscious?
Chidambaram. He was upset at the CBI giving a cleanThat the act of shoe-throwing had become a symbol
chit to Jagdish Tytler, one of the key accused in theof people’s expression of frustration with their
1984 anti-Sikh riots case. Tytler had by then alreadypolitical leaders was also reflect by Youth ki Awaaz,
been nominated as the Congress candidate fromwhich said:
North-East Delhi, a step that had angered the SikhAt press conferences and political campaigns,
community that had been waiting for over 25yearsthrowing shoe has emerged as a sign of being aware
for some kind of closure.yet neglected.
Jarnail Singh and his shoe have woken us all from ourHowever, discussions also veered towards the rights
slumber and reminded us of the crimes committed 25and wrongs of the political system and also of the
years ago, in our Nations Capital against the Sikhaction itself.
community – at a time when there was noHad Jarnail Singh or another frustrated individual gone
Television coverage and media as we know it todaythe wrong way a bullet would have been in the place
- a crime for which in Chidambaram’s wordsof Shoe. Is the current government converting
“not enough people have been punished”.humane people like Jarnail into frustrated individuals
The shoe missed it’s mark, but the protestwho are ready to resort to violence ? I think more
registered. It triggered off a larger expression ofthan the government it is the polluted politics.
anti-Congress sentiments among the Sikh populace, aThe answers to justice may not lie in throwing shoes
sentiment that soon gained momentum. Finally, thebut lies in coherent action and action(or initiative) has
Congress bowed to public pressure and withdrew thebeen taken by Jarnail Singh. Right or Wrong is up to
candidatures of Tytler and another similarly accused,you to decide.
Sajjan Kumar, in an attempt to pacify theFlinging shoes at known and senior politicians is
community’s anger.certainly unethical and must be dealt with seriously.
Thanks to Muntadar al-Zaidi, the citizen of this worldBeing against someone or protesting is not bad, but
have a new way to vent out their anger. Eventhe way the protest is carried out must be kept in
though it came very late for George Bush, it came atmind. One must never cross the limits. Their are a
an appropriate time for the Congress. Jarnailnumber of ways through which we can address a
Singh’s act of throwing his Reebok shoes andperson, but certainly not by throwing a shoe.
the subsequent protest from the sikh community hasThis act must be done away with.
forced the Congress to pull back the candidature ofPoliticians have now become wary of the very
Jagdish Tytler and Sajjan Kumar.people they are supposed to be representatives
However, the shoe did not stop there. Soonleaders of. Fearing a shoe-attack, they are taking
shoe-throwing incidents became common fare.preventive measures at their meetings and rallies.
Politicians and electoral candidates such as Navin JindalBewildered politicians are scrambling to find effective
and BJP’s Prime Ministerial candidate, L. K. Advani,solutions to protect themselves. According to various
each received their share of shoe-ing.reports Indian politicians are seeking security measure
Zaidi has inspired a new generation of Indians and hasto help them from these flying weapons of mass
taught them how simple and benign shoes can bedestruction dubbed as Shoegate by Indian media.
used against the State power.Perhaps, it is a wake-up call that the masses are no
[…]longer willing to be passive and detached but wish to
Bear in mind that Indian political class’ culture,be heard loud and clear.