| International cricket's governing body, the ICC, | | | | each challenge is dealt with quickly - the official's |
| appears to think that the answer to this question is | | | | authority is strengthened as players fell less inclined |
| yes. A referral system was suggested for the | | | | to argue with technology. Referrals are also used to |
| England - South Africa series, but the hosts declined | | | | general good effect in rugby. |
| to use the policy and so the forthcoming contest | | | | This referral system has been used on a trial basis |
| between Sri Lanka and India will be first series where | | | | before, but was abandoned after one year in English |
| referrals are tested. | | | | domestic one day cricket. None of the challenges |
| Each team will be allowed three unsuccessful | | | | made by the players resulted in a change of decision, |
| challenges per innings, with only the batsman on the | | | | whilst some apparently incorrect decisions were left |
| receiving end of the decision and the fielding captain | | | | unchallenged. It will be interesting to see if players |
| able to make the challenge. There is therefore not a | | | | actually know when they are out and bowlers might |
| limit on successful challenges, so a flurry of | | | | get a shock when they realise most of their LBW |
| overturned decisions could be embarrassing for the | | | | appeals would indeed have gone over the stumps. |
| on-field umpires. | | | | There will never be 100% accuracy - TV cameras |
| However, they should not feel undermined by | | | | cannot always detect thin edges for example - so |
| technology. It is an extra resource and will endorse | | | | batsman still receive the benefit of doubt to some |
| their good judgement as much as it highlights errors | | | | extent. On-field umpires still make the final decision - |
| that are forgivable in the pressurised environment of | | | | the ICC is keen to point out that the system is for |
| Test cricket. Umpires use technology to help get line | | | | consultation, not referral. |
| calls right in three of the grand slam tournaments and | | | | |