Bryce McGain - Worst Debut in History?

The solemn Bryce McGain Debut. . .seamers. Yes, this has worked for Ponting in the first
Wow! What an introduction (and exit?) fromtwo tests, but this time he had a legitimate reason
international cricket for Australia's new replacementto try out his spinner early on, and give him a fair go.
for Shane Warne. In case you missed it VictorianAs I have written previously, this test presented a
leg-spinner Bryce McGain was ruthlessly murdered bygreat chance for the Aussies to try-out a few
some seriously vengeful South African batsmen inplayers for the upcoming Ashes series.
the third test. McGain's figures read:At the same time, I mentioned that the Australians
18 OVERS 0 WICKETS FOR 149 RUNSdidn't want to lose momentum. However, bowling
Now, on initial reading that may well look as if theMcGain early, and giving him a chance to work his
spinner is solely to blame. An economy rate of 8.27 isway into an innings (a tactic that every spinner needs
pretty bad even for T20, but on the test arena, aemployed) was the right way to go. Waiting until not
disgrace. However, all the blame cannot be placed atonly the opposition batsmen were set, but also until
the debutants feet. As I have mentioned he was athe nerves and uncertainty had built up in McGain's
debutant, and therefore was inevitably going to bemind, was the wrong decision. Sure, the 18 overs
harbouring some serious nerves. Why then would thethemselves are generally the problem of the bowler,
Australian captain feed him to the wolves rather thanalthough some of the fielding positions were
protecting him, and giving him every chance toquestionable. However, you have to give your
overcome those nerves by bowling him AT THEbowlers a chance to succeed, and Ponting must
RIGHT TIME?!?realize that he is going to have to help bring through
By the time McGain was brought on, Ashwell Princea top class spinner at some point.
and Jacques Kallis, both batsmen who average overSure, maybe McGain isn't the answer, but I don't
45 in tests, were well set, and had a belter of a pitchthink that any prospective spinner waiting for a
to feel comfortable on. Through the South Africancall-up will be very exited about the prospects of
innings Ponting stubbornly continued with his onesuch limited support that was afforded McGain.
winning formula, bowling out the opposition with his